I’ve been thinking about my critique group and how it fits into my writing lately. Before I post about some of that though, I thought it would be helpful to have some background on the group I’m a part of. Please keep in mind I am far from an expert in critiquing. A few things of note:
- This is the only group I’ve been a part of, and the only one I’ve started.
- Everyone in this group had met in real life prior to starting the group.
- We meet in person, virtually, or a mix of both once per month.
Last January my friend Cate and I set out to start a critique group. We had both hit the point in our writing where we knew it was time to share, but we weren’t sure of the best way to do that. After reviewing our options, we decided starting our own critique group made the most sense. When we sent out the invitation for people to join our group, we were aiming for a group of four to six people including ourselves.
The group started with five people, but we currently have only three members. We’d love another member or two, but we are an acquired taste in some ways, and I think having now been working together for a while it’s harder to bring in another person.
When we started the group we were very deliberate in setting the tone, structure, and expectations. We talked about what people wanted to get out of the group, and how much time people had to devote to the group. We laid out the ground rules and expectations for members. This really helped when we were getting started and means that going forward we have a plan in place. A few things we discussed/laid out included:
- How long will submissions be, and what is the max number of submissions the group can handle per month?
- When will we submit, how often will we meet, and how will we meet (in person or virtual)?
- What types of writing can be submitted (age and genre), and is there anything someone is not comfortable reviewing?
- What are our guidelines when doing the critique, and how are we sharing our comments with the writer?
- How will we handle people who ask to join, or asking people to join?
Are you part of a critique group? What are some of the ground rules your group follows?